Somewhere inside the foam, the jowls and the flapping sports jacket, Nicolas Cage is having the time of his life. He bellows, he scribbles plays across the screen, he mutters football philosophy at anyone who will listen. As John Madden, the Oakland Raiders coach who became the most famous voice in American football and then the name on one of the biggest video game franchises ever made, Cage throws himself at the part with everything he has. Madden, David O. Russell’s first film since Amsterdam in 2022, almost never gives him anything to push against.
Arriving on Prime Video around the world, and in a handful of US cinemas, on Wednesday 18 November, this is a biopic of a man who was loved by almost everyone, made by a film-maker who seems to have decided that a life without villains does not need drama either. The result is loud, fast and frequently funny-looking, but for long stretches it is curiously hard to care about.

Nicolas Cage gives John Madden everything he has. The film around him gives Madden almost nothing to do.
Movie at a Glance
- UK availability: Streaming on Prime Video from Wednesday 18 November 2026
- US release: Prime Video and selected cinemas from Wednesday 18 November 2026
- Director: David O. Russell
- Writers: David O. Russell and Cambron Clark
- Starring: Nicolas Cage, Christian Bale, Kathryn Hahn, Sienna Miller and John Mulaney, with Shane Gillis
- Cinematography: Robert Richardson
- Running time: 110 minutes
- US rating: R
- Studio: Amazon MGM Studios (a Prime original)
- Genre: Biographical sports drama, inspired by a true story
Viewer Match
- Best for: NFL obsessives, Raiders fans of a certain age and Nicolas Cage completists who want to see him go all in under the prosthetics.
- Maybe skip if: You want a probing drama about John Madden the man, or you have little patience for David O. Russell’s shouty, sketch-like style.
- Mood and pace: Loud, brisk and jokey, closer to broad comedy than sports drama, with very little at stake for most of its 110 minutes.
- Cinema or streaming? Streaming. In the UK it is a Prime Video release, so the sofa is the natural home for it.
- Spoiler level: Spoiler-free: we stay with the shape of Madden’s public life, which is a matter of record.
A Fat Suit, a Telestrator and a Lot of Noise
The film picks Madden up in the mid-1970s, when his Raiders are already winning plenty of games but still chasing a Super Bowl. From there it races through the highlights of a public life that is largely a matter of record: the long-awaited championship, the bleeding ulcer that forces him out of coaching, the restless retirement, the leap into the CBS commentary booth alongside Pat Summerall (Joel Murray), and finally the meeting with Electronic Arts founder Trip Hawkins (John Mulaney) that turns his battered playbook into Madden NFL.
Russell tells all of this in a hurry. There are mock-documentary interviews, plays chalked straight onto the image like a live telestrator, and wall-to-wall period needle drops, all cut together by three credited editors at a pace that rarely lets a scene breathe. For the first half hour that energy is quite fun. By the second hour it starts to feel like a way of avoiding the question the film never answers: what, beyond a love of football, actually drove this man?
Cage Goes All In
Cage’s performance is the reason to watch, and also part of the problem. Buried under heavy prosthetics, he never quite disappears into Madden; you are always aware of the costume, and of an actor enjoying himself enormously inside it. Yet there is real sweetness in the turn. His Madden is a football savant who can seem almost childlike away from the field, a man who forgets how old his sons are but remembers every play he has ever drawn up, and whose fear of flying and love for his family are never in doubt. When the film slows down long enough to let Cage simply be gentle, it briefly comes alive.
Christian Bale, reuniting with Russell after The Fighter, American Hustle and Amsterdam, plays Raiders owner Al Davis with slicked-back hair, a permanent grimace and a thick New York accent. It is a big, mannered performance that looks like it belongs to a crime film, and Bale clearly relishes it. But the friendship between Madden and Davis, which should be the beating heart of the film, is played almost entirely as a double act. The two men squabble over whether Madden should hand his playbook to a video game company, and that is about as deep as it goes.
Wasted Wives and Missing Drama
Kathryn Hahn does her best with Virginia Madden, a woman who has spent years waiting for her husband to come home in more than body. Hahn is one of the sharpest comic actors working, and she brings flashes of warmth and exasperation to a role that mostly asks her to complain and then forgive. Sienna Miller, almost unrecognisable as Carol Davis, is given even less. Every time the film threatens a real crisis in either marriage, it moves on to the next season, the next broadcast or the next song.
That is the deeper issue. Madden’s story is one of success following success, and Russell and co-writer Cambron Clark never find a way to turn that into drama. There is no real antagonist, no serious reversal, and very little sense of what any of this cost anyone. Mulaney’s Hawkins is a thin sketch of a tech visionary, and the closing stretch about the birth of the video game, with its slow march towards better graphics, plays more like brand history than storytelling. Shane Gillis, as an adoring neighbour, adds little.
Bright, Busy and Strangely Weightless
Robert Richardson, a three-time Oscar-winning cinematographer, keeps everything bright and glossy, and the 1970s detail, from the clothes to the hair to the cigarette-smoke locker rooms, is lovingly recreated. Marcelo Zarvos’s score has to compete with a near-constant jukebox of period hits. It all looks expensive and sounds lively, but the effect is oddly weightless, like a highlights reel of a career rather than a portrait of a life.
For viewers who grew up with Madden’s voice on Sunday afternoons, or who sank hours into the game that bears his name, there will be some pleasure in seeing those moments recreated, and in watching Cage and Bale go for broke. Everyone else is likely to find it exhausting. John Madden, who died in 2021 aged 85, was one of American sport’s great characters. This film only rarely makes you understand why.
What the Critics Are Saying
The first reviews, published on 17 November, are largely negative. Tim Grierson in Screen International calls the film “disappointingly shallow and uninquisitive”, while William Bibbiani at TheWrap writes that it is “one of the most insubstantial biopics in an era that’s practically defined by insubstantial biopics.” The Hollywood Reporter’s David Rooney sums it up in one line: “Should come with a concussion warning.” IndieWire’s Vikram Murthi gives it a D+.
One of the warmer early notices comes from Owen Gleiberman in Variety, who describes it as “a stunt biopic on cinematic amphetamines” and concludes that it “keeps you watching, but it also holds you at arm’s length.”
Spoiler-Free Verdict
Madden has a committed, oddly tender Nicolas Cage at its centre and a scenery-chewing Christian Bale beside him, but David O. Russell’s frantic, joke-heavy biopic skates over the life it is meant to explore. Football fans may enjoy the nostalgia and the novelty of Cage under the prosthetics; most viewers will find a film with plenty of noise and very little at stake.
- Performances: 6/10
- Direction: 4.5/10
- Screenplay: 3.5/10
- Score: 5/10
- Cinematography: 6.5/10
- Entertainment Value: 5/10
- Overall score: 5/10
Star rating: 2.5/5
Verdict badge: Skip It
One-line verdict: Nicolas Cage goes all in as John Madden, but David O. Russell’s noisy, drama-free biopic fumbles the story.
Watch the Official Trailer
Nicolas Cage becomes John Madden, with Christian Bale as Al Davis, in the official trailer from Prime Video.
Did you grow up with John Madden in the commentary box or on your games console, and does Nicolas Cage’s take on him work for you? Share your spoiler-free thoughts in the comments.
