Paper Tiger (2026) Super Review: Adam Driver and Miles Teller Are Brothers in Too Deep in James Gray’s Heavyweight Crime Saga

New York, 1986. Irwin Pearl is a decent, careful engineer in Queens, worrying about how to put his two teenage sons through college. Then his older brother Gary, a charming, recently divorced ex-cop with friends at City Hall, turns up at the family table with an opportunity that cannot fail.

Some Russian businessmen have won a contract to clean decades of oil sludge out of the Gowanus Canal, and they need a qualified engineer to sign off a report. The fee is easy money. The men behind it are, Gary promises, just a paper tiger. Paper Tiger, written and directed by James Gray, opens in limited US cinemas this Friday.

Official poster for Paper Tiger
Official poster: NEON.

James Gray makes a family supper feel as dangerous as a shoot-out, and that is the whole point.

Movie at a Glance

  • US release: Limited cinemas from Friday 13 November 2026 (NEON)
  • UK and Ireland release: In cinemas from 5 February 2027
  • Writer and director: James Gray
  • Starring: Adam Driver, Miles Teller and Scarlett Johansson
  • Runtime: 115 minutes
  • US rating: R
  • Genre: Crime drama, thriller

Viewer Match

  • Best for: Fans of James Gray’s We Own the Night and Two Lovers, and of slow-burning, adult crime drama.
  • Maybe skip if: You want a fast, twisty gangster thriller.
  • Mood and pace: Sombre, tense and deliberately paced.
  • Cinema or streaming? Cinema: it is built for a big screen and a quiet room.
  • Spoiler level: Spoiler-free; we only describe the set-up.

Brothers and Bad Deals

Gray has always been drawn to the same territory: working families in the outer boroughs, the pull of loyalty, and the moment a good man realises he has been compromised. Paper Tiger goes straight back there, and it feels like the work of a director completely at home.

The story is simple and gripping. Irwin is flattered that his big brother needs his expertise and dazzled by a fee that could change his sons’ futures. He does not see, until it is far too late, that his signature is the fig leaf for something much uglier. The tension builds through conversations rather than action, and Gray makes every one of them count.

Three Big Performances

Miles Teller is excellent as Irwin, a modest man whose anxiety grows in small, painful steps. Adam Driver is the film’s engine as Gary: handsome, roguish and genuinely convinced he is doing right by his family, even as he drags it towards disaster. It is one of his best performances.

Scarlett Johansson, reuniting with Driver after Marriage Story, is forthright and commanding as Hester, Irwin’s wife and the only adult in the house who is actually doing the parenting. The three of them give weighty, intelligent performances that keep the film anchored even when the plot strains.

Autumn in New York

The look is classic Gray: a permanent late-afternoon autumn of ochres, reds and browns, family dinners shot like confessions, and a city where the police, the mob and the council all seem to run on the same favours. The Russian community in Brighton Beach and the tribal codes of the NYPD are drawn with real texture.

Where it stumbles is plausibility. One or two turns, and one plot device in particular, feel heavier-handed than the rest, and the stately pace will not suit everyone. But this is a serious, substantial film for grown-ups, and it premiered in competition at Cannes to a long standing ovation for good reason.

Where It Fits

For another New York story of small men and big trouble, read our The Only Living Pickpocket in New York Super Review. Everything else opening this week is in this week’s Weekly Cinema Pack, you can see what else is heading to UK and Ireland cinemas in What Is Coming Next: November 2026, and tonight’s TV and streaming picks are in What to Watch Tonight.

Spoiler-Free Verdict

Paper Tiger is a muscular, heartfelt and sombre crime saga, with Adam Driver, Miles Teller and Scarlett Johansson all on fine form. A few creaky plot turns cannot stop it being one of James Gray’s strongest films.

  • Performances: 8.5/10
  • Direction: 8.5/10
  • Screenplay: 7.5/10
  • Score: 7.5/10
  • Cinematography: 8.5/10
  • Entertainment Value: 7.5/10
  • Overall score: 8/10

Star rating: 4/5

Verdict badge: Worth Seeing

One-line verdict: A grown-up crime drama about family, loyalty and very bad deals.

Watch the Official Trailer

Watch the official trailer from NEON.

Trailer courtesy of NEON.

Would you have signed Gary’s report? Tell us in the comments.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top